North American Association of Fisheries Economists

NAAFE Forum 2005 Debate:

Ensuring Fisheries Benefits to All Generations

Daniel Pauly debate presentation (Powerpoint Presentation)

James Wilen debate presentation (Powerpoint Presentation)

A Recording of the Debate Between Daniel Pauly and Jim Wilen

at the

NAAFE THIRD ANNUAL FORUM
UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA
VANCOUVER, BC
MAY 26, 2005

Recorded and divided into 32 tracks by Gunnar Knapp.

• Susan Hanna Opening Remarks (3:27)
• Daniel Pauly Opening Remarks (18:14)
• Jim Wilen Opening Remarks (30:39)
• Pauly Land Salinization (2:56)
• Wilen Land Salinization (2:04)
• Pauly-Fishing Down Food Chain (6:14)
• Wilen-Fishing Down Food Chain (4:52)
• Pauly-We Are Fishing Jellyfish (1:17)
• Wilen Marine Protected Areas (6:50)
• Pauly Marine Protected Areas (4:56)
• Wilen Global Warming (5:29)
• Pauly Science & Policy (4:37)
• Wilen Science & Policy (4:10)
• Hanna Remainder of Debate (1:35)
• Question (4:37)
• Pauly Unfairness of Allocations (0:41)
• Wilen Unfairness of Allocations (3:58)
• Pauly Monkeys Care About Fairness (2:11)
• Wilen Two Problems Require Two Instruments (0:41)
• Copes Property Rights (4:04)
• Wilen Property Rights Response (1:51)
• Gil Silvia Question (1:05)
• Pauly Response to Gil Sylvia Question (0:59)
• Rashid Sumaila Question (1:00)
• Wilen Response to Rashid Sumaila (1:33)
• Knapp Question About Population Growth (1:15)
• Pauly-Need for Restraint (3:59)
• Wilen-Reponse on Restraint (1:50)
• Anderson Resource Rental Question (1:00)
• Pauly Resource Rental Response (2:07)
• Wilen Resource Rental Response (2:12)
• Hanna & Sumaila Closing (3:40)